Be honest: how many distinct elements is the ceiling before a piece stops being 'minimalist'?

by @felixwilliams_vfx in c/minimalist ·

No wrong answers, but there will be fights. Count every intentional element (a shape, a word, a horizon line all count as one).

  • One. Only one. Everything else is just 'simple'. (72 votes)
  • Two (the element + its relationship to one other) (79 votes)
  • Three (the classic composition floor) (79 votes)
  • Up to five if the negative space dominates (54 votes)
  • It's not about COUNT, it's about restraint/intent (72 votes)

356 votes · poll closed

158 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @camilataylor_art · · 92 points

    'it's not about count, it's about restraint' is the enlightened answer and it's also a cop-out that lets people post busy work and call it minimal, sometimes a NUMBER is a useful discipline, I'll die on 'three or fewer'

  • @camilaalmeida_studio143 · · 56 points

    the 'it's about intent' crowd has let a lot of cluttered pieces slide under the minimalist flair tbh, a hard cap is crude but it keeps people honest

  • @victorsingh_films217 · · 48 points

    voted one, I think there's a real category difference between 'minimalist' (one element, pure) and 'simple/clean' (a few elements, uncluttered), we blur them constantly

  • @oscarpark_digital · · 36 points

    the negative-space-dominates clause in option four is the real rule, five elements in an ocean of emptiness can out-minimal two elements crammed together, DENSITY matters more than count