My ffmpeg VHS-degrade recipe that does not look like a one-click Premiere plugin
Everyone's VHS look is the same because they all use the same plugin preset. Here is a chain that gives you the real nasty analog thing.
The key insight: real VHS damage is chroma-only. The luminance stays mostly sharp, it is the COLOR that smears and bleeds. Most plugins blur everything equally and that is why they look fake.
Rough chain:
Downscale to 480-ish, back up. Cheap but essential.
Separate chroma, horizontal-blur ONLY the chroma channels, offset them a pixel or two.
Add a faint horizontal sync wobble (a tiny sine on the x-offset).
1 or 2 percent noise, luma only.
Very slight vertical chroma smear for the 'tracking' feel.
Full filtergraph is long so I put it in a gist, link in comments. Tweak the chroma offset to taste, that is the money knob.