Hot take: 'editorial' has become a crutch word that means nothing now

by @ravinguyen in c/portrait-studio · · Editorial

Every third post here is flaired 'Editorial' and 80% of them are just a normal headshot with a grey background and a serious face. That's not editorial, that's a passport photo with attitude.

Editorial portraiture has a POINT OF VIEW. It's lit and composed to say something — power, vulnerability, tension. There's a reason the subject is cropped like that, lit like that. 'Serious person, grey seamless, slight rim light' is a default, not an editorial statement.

Not trying to gatekeep the flair, just... if you can't say in one sentence what your editorial portrait is arguing, it's probably a beauty shot that wandered into the wrong flair.

97 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @oliviasmith_studio · · 97 points

    You're being a snob but you're a correct snob. 'Grey seamless + serious face' is the 'lofi beats to study to' of portraiture. Technically a vibe, not a statement.

  • @evelynmillerworks · · 54 points

    correct snob is the best kind of snob. carry on correctly snobbing.

  • @jingarciacreative · · 69 points

    downvoting because the tone is insufferable, upvoting in my heart because you're right, net zero, congratulations

  • @zarapatel_art · · 84 points

    Counterpoint: a clean editorial beauty headshot is a legit commercial category and not everything needs to 'argue' something. Sometimes the brief is 'make her look powerful and expensive', full stop.

  • @sakuradaviscreative · · 56 points

    'Make her look powerful and expensive' IS a point of view though. That's exactly OP's point — you can name what it's doing. The ones OP's mad about can't.