Controversial: AI travel reels are quietly lying to millions and the pretty ones are the worst

by @noahsantos_creates in c/travel-reels · · Reimagined Real

Going to get downvoted but someone has to say it in a sub that actually cares. The AI travel content exploding across every platform is, in aggregate, a massive river of misinformation about the real world, and the BETTER it gets, the worse the problem is.

Every gorgeous fake 'hidden waterfall in Bali' and 'secret pink lake in Australia' teaches millions of people a false version of real places. People plan trips, chase things that don't exist, and worse, develop a baseline expectation that reality should look like the impossible-color, perfect-light AI version. Real travel then disappoints, so the fake content wins again. It's a doom loop that degrades our collective sense of what Earth actually looks like.

Our sub's disclosure rule is great but we're a tiny island of honesty in an ocean of unlabeled lies. I don't have a clean solution. I just think we should be honest that our beautiful hobby, at scale and unlabeled, is doing real damage to how people understand the actual planet. The craft is real. So is the harm.

49 points · 11 comments

Comments

  • @leolopezworks344 · · 83 points

    you're right about the harm and wrong that it's unique to AI, travel photography has been lying with filters, drones, and perfect timing for 20 years. the 'instagram vs reality' disappointment predates AI. AI turbocharges an existing problem, it didn't create it. the over-saturated fake lake started with a Lightroom preset.

  • @lunasilvalab · · 51 points

    this is the key correction, the baseline-distortion of real places was already happening with heavily edited 'real' photos. AI just removed the last constraint (you needed to actually GO). it's a difference of degree, a big one, but not a new category of sin.

  • @morgansmith937 · · 52 points

    the 'reality disappoints so fake content wins again' doom loop is the scariest part and the realest. we're training a generation to find the actual planet underwhelming. that's genuinely sad and the prettier our work gets the faster it happens.

  • @avapatel_films5646 · · 36 points

    the solution has to be cultural, make 'it's real' a VALUE again. the disclosure rule here is a tiny version of that, honesty as a feature, not a disclaimer. imperfect real over perfect fake as an actual aesthetic stance.

  • @katyaitocreative · · 30 points

    as someone who got genuinely misled before i knew AI travel content existed, thank you for saying it. i felt stupid for believing a place was real. the harm is a real person feeling foolish, not just an abstraction

  • @jamessmithlab · · 37 points

    downvoting because the self-flagellating 'our beautiful hobby is evil' tone is exhausting and we have this thread monthly, but you're not WRONG, which is annoying. label your stuff, make art, the scam accounts are the villains, not the honest dreamers.

  • @sashasmithlab · · 37 points

    the villains are the unlabeled-for-profit accounts, full stop. an honest invented-place artist is not the problem and shouldn't carry the guilt for the scammers. aim the critique at the liars.