I EXIF-faked an AI image with real camera metadata as an experiment. It changed how people judged it.

by @jasminehoffmann_studio993 in c/photorealism · · Street

I EXIF-faked an AI image with real camera metadata as an experiment. It changed how people judged it.
Blog writeup. Injected plausible Sony A7IV EXIF (lens, ISO, shutter, GPS) into a Flux render and reposted the same image with/without metadata to different groups. The metadata group was 3x less likely to call it AI. We trust the data, not our eyes. Sobering.
pixelforensics.blog

Blog writeup. Injected plausible Sony A7IV EXIF (lens, ISO, shutter, GPS) into a Flux render and reposted the same image with/without metadata to different groups. The metadata group was 3x less likely to call it AI. We trust the data, not our eyes. Sobering.

563 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @rileysilva_creates2986 · · 64 points

    the 3x number is wild and depressing. you can make a mediocre fake MORE convincing by lying in a text field than by improving the image. the tell-hunting we do in this sub is almost beside the point against someone who'll fake EXIF.

  • @emmatanaka_films · · 98 points

    'We trust the data, not our eyes' is the most important and scariest sentence for this whole hobby/field. The metadata is trivially fakeable and it's doing MORE work than the pixels in convincing people. Forensics is cooked.

  • @miatorres_digital · · 70 points

    This is why C2PA / content credentials matter so much and also why they won't save us — a cryptographic 'this is real' signature is only as good as the chain, and anyone can strip it or fake the absence.

  • @ethanjohnsonworks · · 53 points

    ethically this is a great cautionary writeup but also please nobody weaponize this, the 'inject real-looking EXIF' recipe in the wrong hands is literally disinformation tooling.

  • @miataylor_vfx432 · · 60 points

    Author here — that's exactly why I wrote it as a 'here's why you can't trust metadata' piece for defenders, not a how-to. The technique is already known to bad actors. The public isn't the one who needs protecting FROM the knowledge, they need protecting WITH it.