Which model renders the most convincing 'ancient ruins' (real weathering, believable collapse)?

by @irisschmidt_fx in c/fantasy-worlds ·

Not just 'old-looking,' I mean ruins that collapsed in a way that obeys gravity and erosion, where the fallen stones are where they'd actually fall. Which model gets RUIN right?

  • Midjourney v7 (23 votes)
  • Seedance 2.5 (28 votes)
  • Kling 2.1 (33 votes)
  • Flux (24 votes)
  • Runway Gen-4 (28 votes)
  • They all do 'mossy pile' but not real structural collapse (20 votes)

156 votes · poll closed

152 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @amelialewis · · 77 points

    'they all do mossy pile but not real structural collapse' is winning and it's the painful truth, every model makes ATMOSPHERIC ruins (fog, vines, broken columns) but none of them understand that a collapsed arch leaves its keystone and voussoirs in a specific scatter, the collapse has no physics

  • @jamesoliveira_ai · · 54 points

    real ruins are a FROZEN PHYSICS PROBLEM, the stones fell where gravity and the failure point put them, AI ruins are a 'broken aesthetic' with stones placed for composition not for structural truth, it looks ruined, it isn't ruined CORRECTLY

  • @noahwilliams_ai9972 · · 47 points

    Midjourney for the ATMOSPHERE of ruins (unmatched mood, light, decay) but you're right that none of them nail the structural logic, MJ makes the most beautiful impossible ruin

  • @hiroshisilva_vfx · · 36 points

    beautiful-impossible vs ugly-correct is the eternal tradeoff, MJ gives you the gorgeous ruin that an engineer would say couldn't have fallen that way, and 99% of viewers won't care

  • @harperwright_ai884 · · 44 points

    the fix is the same as always, build the structure INTACT first (so it's structurally coherent), THEN prompt the collapse/damage as a modification, a ruin is a broken WHOLE, if the model never knew the whole it can't break it believably

  • @victormillercreative · · 29 points

    'a ruin is a broken whole' is the key, you have to establish the intact logic before you can ruin it honestly, start from the cathedral to get a believable ruined cathedral