Unpopular: AI still cannot do a believable engine bay and I am tired of pretending. Prove me wrong

by @yukitorres_digital554 in c/automotive · · Engine Bay

Every 'engine bay' post I see is beautiful nonsense. Hoses that connect to nothing, a belt routing that would grenade the motor, two alternators, an intake manifold feeding a battery. It LOOKS mechanical, it is mechanically insane.

Models learned what an engine bay looks like as a texture, not what it IS as a system. For a sub that has car people in it, the engine bay is where the illusion dies hardest, because we know what those parts do.

Post me ONE AI engine bay where a mechanic could not find a fatal error in thirty seconds. I will wait. I do not think it exists yet.

34 points · 11 comments

Comments

  • @zaraguptacreative · · 96 points

    You are correct and it is for the same reason AI hands were hard: an engine bay is a system of functional relationships, and diffusion models learn appearance, not function. It renders 'engine-bay-ish' the way it used to render 'hand-ish'. The parts are plausible, the PLUMBING is hallucinated.

  • @quinnmeyermedia492 · · 59 points

    OP - 'it renders engine-bay-ish' is exactly it. It is the hands problem one layer deeper, because even a correct-LOOKING bay can be functionally impossible and only we notice.

  • @meikapoormedia · · 51 points

    i render engine bays specifically BECAUSE they are insane, mechanical cronenberg is an aesthetic, two alternators is a design choice actually

  • @benjaminrodriguez_motion · · 35 points

    the 'impossible machine' genre is real and valid but call it that, do not tag it Retro/Classic like it is a correct restoration lol

  • @rileycosta_studio331 · · 39 points

    downvoted the attitude, upvoted the content, a classic come-at-me post that is annoyingly correct

  • @kaiyamamotocreative · · 62 points

    Counterpoint with receipts: if you use a real engine-bay photo as a strong img2img/ControlNet base at low denoise, it CANNOT hallucinate the plumbing because you are constraining the structure. The 'AI can't do it' cases are all pure text2img. Guide it with a real reference and it is fine.

  • @caseyhill_ai64 · · 41 points

    OP - ok this is the strongest rebuttal and I will concede it. ControlNet off a real bay is basically 'AI reskin of a correct system', which sidesteps my whole complaint. Pure prompt still fails though, which was my actual point.