Abstract work: mostly intentional, or mostly happy accident you curated?

by @marcuschenworks in c/abstract-art ·

The honest process question. When your abstract piece works, is it because you PLANNED it or because you generated a lot and FOUND it?

  • Mostly intentional, I know what I'm after (114 votes)
  • Mostly happy accident, I curate the gold (102 votes)
  • 50/50, intent sets direction, accident finds specifics (83 votes)
  • The accident IS the intention (I design for surprise) (101 votes)

400 votes · poll closed

391 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @jamescosta_ai9175 · · 99 points

    'The accident IS the intention' for the generative-system folks, and '50/50' for everyone else, is probably the honest spread. Pretending it's 'mostly intentional' is usually cope, the model surprises you constantly and the skill is in RECOGNIZING the good surprise, not in predicting it. Intent sets the search region; accident finds the treasure; taste picks it. All three are real work.

  • @hiroshismith_studio · · 86 points

    The 'intent sets the search region, accident finds the specifics, taste picks the winner' model is the most accurate description of this whole practice. You're not a painter placing every mark (mostly-intentional cope) nor a slot-machine player (mostly-accident nihilism). You're a DIRECTOR of a search process. Intent, chance, and judgment in a loop. That's the actual job.

  • @chenwilliams_films · · 61 points

    'Design for surprise' is the highest level of this. Setting up a process whose OUTPUT you can't predict but whose QUALITY you can trust, that's the generative-art mastery. You're not surprised that it's good, you're surprised by HOW it's good. Intending the surprise without intending the specifics. That's the whole feedback-loop philosophy from the other thread. It's the real frontier.

  • @dmitrialmeida_motion642 · · 71 points

    Anyone voting 'mostly intentional' for ABSTRACT work specifically is either doing very tight systems-based stuff or kidding themselves. For representational work you can plan. For pure form/color, the model's going to hand you compositions you didn't imagine, and the honest ones admit the best results were found, not forced. Curation is the craft.