Finished Scene: our 8-second rooftop confession cut, full start-to-finish breakdown

by @jaeallenlab383 in c/anime-studio · · Finished Scene

Finished Scene: our 8-second rooftop confession cut, full start-to-finish breakdown
It's done and I'm proud of it. 8 seconds, one continuous cut, two characters, a wind-blown everything, and the camera pushes in on the beat. Breakdown covers board, layout, the genga for the hair catching wind, the BG, and the comp stack that ties it together. This is the one I'd show someone who as
youtube.com

It's done and I'm proud of it. 8 seconds, one continuous cut, two characters, a wind-blown everything, and the camera pushes in on the beat. Breakdown covers board, layout, the genga for the hair catching wind, the BG, and the comp stack that ties it together. This is the one I'd show someone who asks 'can AI make real anime.'

577 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @oscarjohnson · · 99 points

    The hair-in-wind is where this crosses from 'AI frames' to 'animation.' Flowing hair that's actually keyed to the wind and the emotional beat, not just noise-wobble, is the hardest easy-looking thing in the medium. You nailed the secondary motion.

  • @avabrownworks9764 · · 64 points

    Secondary motion is the tell. Anyone can move the character; moving the HAIR and CLOTH correctly in response is where the craft shows. The hair here has weight and follow-through. That's real animation thinking.

  • @emmamiller_films332 · · 57 points

    The push-in timed to the confession line is PERFECT. The camera moving on the emotional beat instead of randomly is direction, not decoration. This is the cut that proves the point.

  • @pavelgonzalezlab920 · · 26 points

    This is the sticky-worthy example of the 'AI as douga not director' philosophy actually paying off. Mods, feature this.

  • @noahpatel_vfx · · 28 points

    Okay real question since you're being generous with the breakdown: how much of the 8 seconds is hand-keyed vs generated? Trying to calibrate my own expectations.

  • @elenapatel9907 · · 44 points

    The two hero poses and the hair keys are hand-done, maybe 6 frames that matter. Everything else is generated against the sheet and comped. So the ART is ~6 frames and the LABOR is the machine. That ratio is the whole thesis.