My noise-to-feedback loop in ComfyUI for pure generative texture — graph walkthrough

by @ethankimlab5320 in c/abstract-art · · Generative

For the generative-process folks. I've been making non-objective texture by feeding a model's output back into itself through a controlled feedback loop, letting pure noise evolve into structure over iterations, no prompt subject at all, just the system finding its own forms.

The loop:
Start with pure Perlin noise.
Light denoise pass (low denoise strength, like 0.3) with an EMPTY or purely-textural prompt.
Feed the output back as the input.
Repeat 15-30 times, slowly raising then lowering denoise.

The forms that EMERGE are genuinely not designed by me, they're the model's own attractor states, the shapes it drifts toward when left to iterate on itself. It's the closest thing to true generative art in the Sol LeWitt 'the system makes the art' sense. I set up the process; the process makes the image. I'm often surprised by what emerges, which is the whole point.

546 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @ariabrown_studio · · 78 points

    The denoise strength schedule (raise then lower) is clearly where the craft is. Too high and it reinvents chaos every loop, too low and it stagnates into mush. Finding the schedule that lets forms EMERGE and STABILIZE without either dissolving or freezing is the whole art. Care to share your exact curve?

  • @lunaleeworks · · 61 points

    Roughly: start ~0.3, ramp to ~0.5 around iteration 8-10 (that's where forms crystallize), then back down toward 0.2 to let them settle and sharpen. But honestly every model wants a different curve, it's all feel. The ramp-up finds structure, the ramp-down commits to it. Like sculpting with a dial.

  • @leotaylor_art · · 99 points

    The feedback loop surfacing the model's 'attractor states' is a genuinely deep observation. Every model has characteristic forms it drifts toward when you iterate on its own output, a fingerprint of its training. You're not making images, you're REVEALING the model's latent tendencies. That's conceptually rich generative art.

  • @masonmuellerworks · · 100 points

    This is the real 'generative' in the LeWitt sense that most AI art ISN'T. Typing a prompt and getting an image is not generative art, it's commissioned art. Setting up a SYSTEM that produces unpredictable results you didn't design, THAT'S generative. The feedback loop is a genuine generative system. Rare to see it done with intent here.

  • @dianabrown_films7474 · · 64 points

    This is the most genuinely interesting technical post I've seen here in weeks. Everyone else is prompting pretty colors, you're doing actual systems-based generative art. The emergent-forms-as-model-fingerprint angle alone is worth a whole essay. More of this please.