WIP: scoring my own AI film and realizing the MUSIC is quietly directing the whole thing

by @sophiadavis_vfx in c/ai-filmmakers · · WIP

WIP flair. Mid-way through posting my short and I made a discovery that reorganized my brain: I recut the same sequence against three different temp scores and it became three different films. Same images. The music decided whether it was tense, melancholy, or hopeful.

It made me realize I'd been treating music as the last 5% garnish when it's actually a co-director. The images are more ambiguous than I thought and the score is TELLING THE AUDIENCE HOW TO FEEL about them.

Now I'm scoring EARLY, before locking picture, and letting the music inform the cut instead of the other way around. Anyone else work music-first? Does it change your edit as much as it's changing mine?

126 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @meigupta_films · · 100 points

    Music as co-director is 100% correct and it's MORE true for AI film than traditional, because AI footage is often emotionally ambiguous — the performances are subtle-to-blank, so the score has to carry the emotional read. The music isn't garnish, it's the performance.

  • @hiroshipatel_art4538 · · 87 points

    This is a brilliant point. When your 'actors' have limited emotional range, the score becomes the actor. It's doing the work the face can't yet do. Scoring early isn't just good practice for AI, it might be NECESSARY.

  • @zaranguyen_art · · 72 points

    The three-temp-scores experiment is a classic film school exercise for exactly this reason and every single person is stunned by it the first time. The music makes the meaning. Welcome to the truth.

  • @ravikim_vfx4330 · · 48 points

    The Kuleshov effect but for emotion via sound. Same shot, different score, different film. It never stops being magic.

  • @takeshishah_studio · · 54 points

    I score-first now too and it reordered my whole process. The music gives the edit a SPINE to cut against. Cutting to picture-first with music-later is building a house then deciding where the beams go.

  • @dianacosta_ai · · 43 points

    Careful not to let a borrowed temp score seduce you into a cut that your final (original/licensed) music can't support. The temp-love trap is real — editors fall for a temp and nothing else ever satisfies.

  • @skylersouza_creates · · 29 points

    Oof, the temp-love trap. Good warning. I'm commissioning the real score to the SHAPE of the temp, not a specific track, to avoid exactly this.