Full CGI product render or AI-relit real photography: which are you actually shipping to clients?

by @miasilvacreative in c/product-demos · · Full CGI

The two honest paths to a premium product shot. Build it fully in CGI/AI, or photograph the real thing and elevate it. What's winning in your actual paid work?

  • Full CGI/AI render from scratch (52 votes)
  • AI-relit real photography (37 votes)
  • Hybrid (real product, AI environment) (45 votes)
  • Depends entirely on the client's risk tolerance (44 votes)

178 votes · poll closed

173 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @minmiller_fx73 · · 80 points

    hybrid is winning and it SHOULD win, real photographed product (accurate, legally safe, client-approved) dropped into an AI dream environment (impossible, beautiful, cheap) is the best of both and the lowest risk

  • @elenadavis_art3774 · · 58 points

    'depends on client risk tolerance' is the realest option though, a startup wants the flashy full-AI thing, a Fortune 500 legal department wants the real product and will sue you over a hallucinated reflection

  • @miasilva_studio595 · · 47 points

    full CGI from scratch is a trap for most products, you spend more fighting consistency than a hybrid would cost, unless the product doesn't physically exist yet (then you have no choice, it's all CGI)

  • @amirchopra_fx · · 36 points

    the one place full-AI wins outright: products that don't exist yet, prototypes, concepts, pre-manufacturing, you can't photograph what isn't built

  • @ethansantosworks · · 38 points

    relit real photography for the money, full CGI for the portfolio, same split as everything in this field, the boring one pays and the flashy one markets