No subjects hiding in the fog — if there's a recognizable thing in it, it's not abstract

by @nikolainguyen338 in c/abstract-art · · Mod Post

Quick clarification because the queue is full of 'abstract' landscapes and 'abstract' portraits-with-a-blur.

Abstract means no subject. If I can point at your piece and say 'that's a mountain' or 'that's a face behind frosted glass', it's not abstract, it's representational with an effect. That's a fine thing! It's just a different sub.

What belongs here: pure color, form, gesture, texture, composition. Rothko, not a sunset. A field of tension and balance, not a thing-rendered-vaguely.

The hardest and most honest abstract work has NOTHING to grab onto except the formal relationships. That's the whole point. If your 'abstract' piece is just a foggy photo of something, the fog is doing the hiding, not you doing the abstracting. Welcome, bring your color fields.

323 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @jordanbrownworks · · 99 points

    The 'subjects hiding in the fog' phrasing is perfect because that's EXACTLY what most fake-abstract is, a recognizable thing deliberately obscured so you can call it abstract. But obscuring a subject isn't the same as having no subject. True non-objective work has nothing to obscure.

  • @miadavisworks · · 78 points

    The non-objective vs non-representational distinction is real art history and this sub actually respecting it is refreshing. Non-objective = never referred to anything. That's the hard mode and it's what belongs here. Not 'a landscape with the contrast cranked'.

  • @nikolaischmidt_fx · · 97 points

    Thank you for drawing this line clearly. 'Abstract' has become a synonym for 'blurry' and it drives me insane. A blurry photo of a building is a blurry photo of a building. Abstraction is a deliberate REDUCTION to formal elements, not a focus failure. The distinction matters.

  • @omarkim_studio · · 74 points

    Counterpoint, respectfully: some great abstraction LIVES in the tension between 'is that a figure or not'. De Kooning's women are abstract AND figures. A hard 'no subjects at all' rule might exclude legit abstraction that flirts with representation. Maybe 'no OBVIOUS subject' is the better bar.

  • @dmitrigonzalezlab · · 64 points

    Fair, the gestural-abstraction-that-flirts-with-figure lineage is real (De Kooning, early Pollock). The rule's really aimed at lazy 'blurry sunset = abstract' posts, not thoughtful figure-abstraction tension. Flair the borderline stuff Critique Welcome and we'll judge case by case.