Critique Welcome: my first 32x32 knight sprite. Something's off about the readability and I can't name it.
Been doing pixel art for about two months, all by hand in Aseprite. This is a 32x32 knight for a game jam. 8 colors. I think the proportions are okay but at 1x (actual size, no zoom) it reads as mush and I can't figure out why. At 8x it looks fine to me.
Specific things I'm unsure about:
The helmet — is the plume reading as a plume or as a random blob?
The sword feels like it disappears into the body
I used a dark outline everywhere, is that the problem?
Full selout vs black outline, I don't fully understand when to use which yet. Roast it, I want to actually get better, not get told it's great.