Critique Welcome: my first 32x32 knight sprite. Something's off about the readability and I can't name it.

by @liamsmith_ai in c/pixel-art · · Critique Welcome

Been doing pixel art for about two months, all by hand in Aseprite. This is a 32x32 knight for a game jam. 8 colors. I think the proportions are okay but at 1x (actual size, no zoom) it reads as mush and I can't figure out why. At 8x it looks fine to me.

Specific things I'm unsure about:
The helmet — is the plume reading as a plume or as a random blob?
The sword feels like it disappears into the body
I used a dark outline everywhere, is that the problem?

Full selout vs black outline, I don't fully understand when to use which yet. Roast it, I want to actually get better, not get told it's great.

132 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @dianajohnsonworks · · 99 points

    The readability problem is CONTRAST, not detail. At 1x your sword and body are too close in value, so the eye can't separate them. Pixel art reads at a distance by VALUE grouping first, color second, detail last. Squint at it — if you can't tell the shapes apart squinting, neither can anyone at 1x.

  • @morganhernandez_creates · · 88 points

    the squint test is the single most useful pixel art trick and nobody tells beginners about it. squint, if the silhouette and the big value shapes don't read, no amount of detail will save it.

  • @nikolaimiller_vfx · · 52 points

    the plume reads as a blob because it has no internal value structure. even at 32x32 you can get 2 values of plume to show it's a soft feathery mass. one flat color = blob. two values = plume. that's the whole trick at small sizes: imply form with the minimum values.

  • @miasantoslab203 · · 75 points

    on the outline question: pure black outline everywhere FLATTENS pixel art and that's part of your mush. look into 'selective outlining' (selout) — darker shade of the local color instead of black, and dropping the outline entirely where a shape meets a lighter background. black outline is a crutch we all start with and then unlearn.

  • @hanasilva_vfx1355 · · 48 points

    selout changed my whole style once it clicked. black outlines make everything look like stickers pasted on. colored outlines make it look like it belongs in the world.