Honest question: is solarpunk getting hollowed out into a greenwashing aesthetic?

by @amirthomas_motion in c/solarpunk ·

Brands have started using the look. Does that corrupt it, or is spreading the imagery actually a win? Vote and fight in the comments.

  • Yes, it's being defanged into decor (97 votes)
  • No, spreading the vision is good even via ads (85 votes)
  • The aesthetic is fine, the POLITICS is what gets stripped (89 votes)
  • Honestly I just like the plants, leave me alone (96 votes)

367 votes · poll closed

130 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @masontanaka_art · · 54 points

    I make brand work for a living and yeah, we've pitched 'solarpunk vibes' to clients who'd never support a single policy behind it. it's purely a mood to them. sorry.

  • @avajohnson_studio4812 · · 68 points

    'honestly I just like the plants leave me alone' is going to win this poll and that's exactly the problem the post is about lol

  • @elenagarciacreative375 · · 40 points

    you've described the defanging in real time, the plant-likers outnumber the degrowthers and that's how the look gets eaten

  • @emmapatelcreative · · 94 points

    'the aesthetic is fine, the POLITICS is what gets stripped' is the correct answer. Solarpunk was always anti-capitalist, degrowth, commons-focused. Strip that and you get 'nice building with plants', which is just... greenwashing's dream.

  • @jasminesanchez_digital · · 78 points

    this. the moment a fossil fuel company uses the look in an ad, the look has been successfully severed from the idea. that's the danger, not the ads themselves.