Blind test: one of these 6 'product shots' is a real photo. Vote before you scroll comments.

by @katyamueller_digital602 in c/photorealism · · Product

Blind test: one of these 6 'product shots' is a real photo. Vote before you scroll comments.
Watch bottle, five AI, one shot on my phone in a lightbox. Guess the real one in the poll image, I'll reveal in 24h. No peeking at EXIF, I stripped it all.
imgur.com

Watch bottle, five AI, one shot on my phone in a lightbox. Guess the real one in the poll image, I'll reveal in 24h. No peeking at EXIF, I stripped it all.

625 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @dianagarcia_art · · 96 points

    #4. The others all have that too-clean reflection on the glass. #4's reflection is slightly blown out and messy in a way the AI ones 'fixed'. Real light is sloppier.

  • @felixjohnsoncreative · · 71 points

    Going #4 too and for the same reason — the AI ones all have PERFECT dust-free surfaces. #4 has a tiny smudge near the base. The flaw is the tell for REAL now.

  • @emmapatel_films · · 54 points

    I said #2 and I was wrong, #2's label text is actually legible which fooled me into thinking real, but apparently that's just a very good inpaint job. the one tell I trust (text) was faked. unsettling.

  • @nikolaigarcia_art · · 47 points

    product is almost the HARDEST category to fake because it's all reflections and precise geometry and legible branding. nailing a believable product shot is black-belt stuff. respect the test.