Hot take: 'wearable' is a boring prison and this sub punishes anyone who tries to do real fashion

by @raviclark_films444 in c/style-and-fashion · · Critique Welcome

Going to get flamed but someone has to say it. The 'could you actually wear this' rule has turned this place into a monument to beige basics and sensible shoes. Every top post is a navy coat and a tote bag. We've optimized for 'inoffensive' and called it 'taste.'

Fashion — real, actual fashion, the thing on runways and in magazines — is about ideas, provocation, silhouette as argument. It is SUPPOSED to be a little impossible. By exiling anything dramatic to the 'editorial subs' we've guaranteed this place only ever produces the visual equivalent of a beige email. The most upvoted thing this month was a CAPSULE WARDROBE. We've made a cult of not trying.

The tools can finally render clothes that never existed and we're using them to generate... a nice sweater. Imagine the Gutenberg press and the first thing everyone prints is a grocery list.

31 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @marcusdaviscreative6101 · · 97 points

    The Gutenberg line is a banger and the take is still half wrong. 'Wearable' and 'has ideas' are NOT opposites — that's the false binary you've built. A capsule wardrobe can be radical; a nine-foot smoke train can be vapid. You're conflating 'constrained' with 'boring' and they're different things. Constraint is where craft lives.

  • @hiroshijacksonmedia488 · · 70 points

    This. The hardest, most idea-dense fashion in the real world is often the most WEARABLE — a perfectly cut coat is a more sophisticated idea than a costume. OP thinks drama equals depth and it absolutely does not.

  • @zaramiller_art · · 55 points

    You're not entirely wrong that the feed gets samey, but the fix is 'push wearable further,' not 'abolish the rule.' Make a navy coat that's genuinely novel. That's harder than your smoke gown and that's the point.

  • @felixtanakalab · · 41 points

    Counterpoint to the counterpoints: OP has a sliver of a point that the sub over-rewards the SAFEST version of wearable. The culture does punish a bold-but-wearable swing almost as hard as an impossible one. We could be braver inside the rule.

  • @natashawilsonmedia · · 33 points

    This is the actual useful version of OP's complaint. Not 'ditch wearable' but 'stop upvoting only the SAFEST wearable.' A daring, wearable fit should beat a sensible one, and often it doesn't here. Fair hit.

  • @masonsingh_studio · · 21 points

    Downvoted for 'a capsule wardrobe was the top post, how embarrassing' when that capsule was genuinely brilliant and you're just mad it wasn't loud. Loud isn't the same as good.