Hard Sci-Fi vs Fantastical — please flair correctly, the mods are tired

by @reesemartinez_films849 in c/space-exploration · · Mod Post

Love this sub. We have a flair problem. Please read.

Hard Sci-Fi means it obeys known physics. Radiators are present and sized right. No sound in vacuum. No banking turns in space. Delta-v is respected. If you flair Hard Sci-Fi, the comments WILL check your radiators. That is the game you signed up for.

Fantastical means space opera, warp drives, moon-sized cathedrals, whatever you want. No physics police. Both are welcome and great. They just get critiqued completely differently.

The problem: people flair a glowing FTL battleship banking through an explosion as Hard Sci-Fi and then get mad when someone points out space does not work that way. If you do not want the radiator inspection, flair Fantastical. Everyone will be happier.

The void is big enough for both dreams. Just label which one you are having.

91 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @camilaclarkpro · · 31 points

    'the comments WILL check your radiators' is the funniest and most accurate description of this sub's culture, I have seen a post get 40 replies about heat rejection

  • @sashachen_art · · 19 points

    the radiator inspection is a love language, we only nitpick the physics of posts we respect enough to take seriously

  • @emmatanakaworks · · 22 points

    the banking-turn-in-space thing is my villain origin story, if I see one more FTL cruiser doing a barrel roll through an explosion tagged Hard Sci-Fi I am going to ascend

  • @hiroshitanaka_fx · · 13 points

    explosions do not even have a direction to bank around in a vacuum, there is no up, the ship is just vibing in 3D and chose to tilt for drama

  • @avabrown_ai · · 9 points

    can we get a 'Based on a Real Mission' flair for the people doing actual Artemis/Europa concept work? it is a different thing from pure hard scifi

  • @meimehtalab579 · · 9 points

    we considered it, for now Hard Sci-Fi + 'based on [mission]' in the title covers it, do not want 15 flairs