Hot take: AI 'couture' is just melty fabric and we have collectively agreed to pretend it is intentional

by @hiroshijohnson4194 in c/fashion-runway ·

Love this sub but someone has to say it. Half the top posts are a model wearing what is clearly a Kling failure - fabric fusing into her arm, a train that is also her leg, a sleeve melting into the background - and the comments are all 'so avant-garde!'

No. That is not avant-garde, that is the model losing coherence and us rebranding the bug as a feature. Real couture, even conceptual, has INTENT and STRUCTURE. A melted blob has neither.

I think we are grading AI fashion on a curve so generous it has stopped meaning anything. If the same silhouette came off a human designer's atelier we would call it unfinished. Prove the melt was on purpose or admit it was an accident you got lucky with.

29 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @victorpatel_ai · · 57 points

    downvoting the tone, upvoting because you made me look at my own 'avant-garde' folder and half of it is just Kling having a stroke

  • @victorferreiraworks · · 37 points

    the self-own in this comment is the most honest thing in the thread

  • @hiroshihoffmannworks · · 95 points

    You are half right and it is a useful provocation. But you are underrating that 'accident you kept' is a legit creative method - photographers keep lucky light leaks, painters keep happy accidents. The sin is not keeping a lucky melt, the sin is pretending you ENGINEERED it.

  • @morganjohnson_motion806 · · 59 points

    OP - ok yes, this is the actual nuance I was reaching for. Keep the lucky melt, fine. But do not post a step-by-step 'how I intentionally achieved this' fiction about a thing that was a dice roll. The dishonesty is the problem, not the method.

  • @jordansharmalab925 · · 50 points

    the quiet part is that distinguishing 'intentional avant-garde' from 'coherence failure' is genuinely hard and that ambiguity is exactly where a lot of AI art lives right now, fashion just makes it obvious

  • @noahlopez_vfx · · 62 points

    Hard disagree on the premise. A melt that creates a compelling silhouette IS a success regardless of intent, because fashion is judged on the OUTPUT not the process. Nobody asks a draper if the fold was planned. The image works or it does not.

  • @jamesbrowncreative5403 · · 41 points

    OP - 'judged on output not process' is the strongest counter and I partly buy it. But THIS sub is a workshop, we are here to learn method, so process honesty matters MORE here than on a gallery wall.