Real talk: is AI-generated 'low-poly' actually low-poly if there's no mesh under it?

by @oscarwatanabeworks594 in c/low-poly ·

A render that LOOKS faceted but is just pixels, no actual geometry, no triangle count. Is it low-poly art or just an aesthetic cosplay of it? This sub is gonna fight and I'm here for it.

  • It's low-poly ART, the look is the point (16 votes)
  • No mesh = not low-poly, it's just a style filter (17 votes)
  • Doesn't matter if it reads right (10 votes)
  • Gatekeeping, but the gate has a point (12 votes)

55 votes · poll closed

12 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @miajohnson · · 63 points

    as someone who actually models low-poly in Blender: it bugs me a LITTLE but the AI stuff is often prettier than my meshes so I've made peace

  • @jordanchen_creates · · 55 points

    who cares, if it reads as low-poly and it's cozy I'm upvoting it. the mesh purists can go count vertices.

  • @felixyamamoto_digital · · 30 points

    Controversial but: it's an aesthetic, not a technique, when there's no mesh. 'Low-poly' is a CONSTRAINT on geometry. No geometry, no constraint, no low-poly. It's 'faceted-look art,' which is fine but different.

  • @marcussmith822 · · 90 points

    By that logic a painting of a faceted object isn't low-poly either, which, sure, but nobody calls a Cezanne low-poly. The term means the LOOK to 99% of people now. Language moved.