How I fake a LOADED brush and real gesture without the model making a literal 'painting'

by @avamartinezpro in c/abstract-art · · Gestural

The problem with gestural abstraction via AI: prompt 'gestural brushstrokes' and the model gives you a PICTURE of brushstrokes, a rendered photo of a painting, flat, with fake canvas texture and a little frame sometimes. I want the GESTURE itself, the energy of a loaded brush dragged fast, not a photo of someone else's painting.

What's getting me closer:
Prompt the PHYSICS, not the object: 'thick wet paint dragged in a single fast arc, paint piling at the end of the stroke, bristle streaks'. Describe what the brush DID, not 'a brushstroke'.
Avoid 'painting', 'canvas', 'artwork', these pull toward 'photo of a framed painting'. I want to be INSIDE the gesture, not looking at a painting of it.
Generate huge and crop IN, so a single gesture fills the frame and there's no 'painting sitting on a wall' framing.

Still not perfect, the model has a strong prior that 'brushstroke' = 'image of a painting'. Prompting the physical ACTION instead of the noun helps most. Describe the verb, not the noun.

627 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @felixmueller_films6606 · · 86 points

    The 'paint piling at the end of the stroke' detail is the kind of physical specificity that gets you real gesture. That's where a loaded brush runs out and dumps its load, and describing that MOMENT gives the model something physical to render instead of a generic smear. Specificity of the physical event = authenticity.

  • @sophiatorres_vfx · · 99 points

    'Describe the verb, not the noun' is a genuinely great prompting principle that goes way beyond abstract art. 'Brushstroke' (noun) gets you a picture OF a brushstroke. 'Paint dragged fast' (verb/action) gets you the GESTURE. The model renders actions more immediately than objects. This is a real insight.

  • @alexandermiller_art909 · · 100 points

    The noun 'brushstroke' is loaded with 'this is a painting' context in the training data, so the model gives you the whole painting-photo package. The verb phrase strips that context and leaves just the physical event. You're routing around the noun's baggage. Same energy as the vintage sub's 'poisoned token' thread.

  • @sashasantos_studio · · 64 points

    Cropping IN to eliminate the 'painting on a wall' framing is the move I was missing. My gestural stuff always had that subtle 'here is a photo of an artwork' vibe and it's because the model framed it as an object. Fill the frame with the gesture and it becomes immersive. Thank you.