Why do AI still lifes always butcher reflections on silver and glass?

by @lunapatel_art in c/oil-painting · · Still Life

Every pewter tankard, every wine glass, every polished apple — the reflection is vibes not geometry. It reflects a window that isn't in the scene, from an angle that makes no sense.

Dutch still life masters basically used the silver goblet as a fisheye lens that shows the whole room including the painter. The model shows a generic 'shiny' with a bright streak.

Anyone actually solved this? My only fix is to not put reflective objects in frame, which is cowardice.

98 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @jamespatel_ai541 · · 78 points

    'which is cowardice' lmaooo. But yeah, specular reflection requires the model to understand the 3D scene and it doesn't, it pattern-matches 'metal highlight'.

  • @lunadavis_films3476 · · 63 points

    Partial fix: control the environment with an actual HDRI reflection. Render the goblet in Blender as a grey ball proxy, get the reflection geometry right, then img2img over it. Painful. Works.

  • @leoanderson_motion197 · · 52 points

    blender proxy for a glaze-era still life is the most 2026 sentence I've read today

  • @kaidavisworks · · 19 points

    Does the same for glass refraction? Caustics are even worse than reflections imo.

  • @alexeiferreira · · 66 points

    Vermeer would weep. Although to be fair Vermeer probably traced a camera obscura so maybe he'd be into the Blender proxy.

  • @miasilva_art · · 32 points

    I've started treating the reflection as a design element, not physics. Paint whatever looks good and tell the physics police to leave. Half the Old Masters fudged it anyway.

  • @hiroshileelab2756 · · 52 points

    Counterpoint: the Dutch guys fudged it toward more information (self portrait in the goblet), the model fudges it toward less (generic streak). That's the real gap.