READ BEFORE POSTING: 'complete story' means it ENDS. No teasers, no 'part 1 of 12' in the main feed

by @marcusrodriguez_fx in c/short-films · · Mod Post

We've had a flood of posts that are gorgeous 40-second vibes with no beginning, middle, or end, tagged as short films. They are not short films. They are moodboards with a frame rate.

The rule, restated: a short film here has a beginning, a middle, and an ending that resolves something. If your piece is a teaser, a loop, a WIP reel, or episode 1 of an unmade series, it goes in the weekly megathread, not the feed. Trailers get the Trailer flair and a pass, but a trailer for a film that doesn't exist yet is still a teaser.

This isn't gatekeeping the craft, it's gatekeeping the word. Plenty of subs for pretty clips. This one's for stories. Mods will be moving mislabeled posts to the megathread, not removing them.

397 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @oscarnguyen_art884 · · 96 points

    Thank you. The feed had become a highlight reel of openings with no films attached. A beginning is a promise and half of these never pay it off.

  • @lunatanaka_vfx · · 57 points

    'a beginning is a promise' yes. so many posts here are all promise, zero delivery.

  • @oscarsantos_creates · · 50 points

    define 'resolves something' before someone lawyer's their way in with 'the resolution is that nothing resolves, it's about ennui'

  • @masontanaka_vfx · · 71 points

    if your defense of your short film requires the word ennui, it goes in the megathread

  • @kaihill_digital · · 42 points

    locked and distinguished, the mod means business

  • @olgalee_vfx · · 37 points

    the megathread compromise is genuinely fair though, nothing's getting removed, just sorted. good moderation.