Macro test reel: ten fabrics (silk, latex, smoke, glass, chainmail) under identical studio light, Kling vs Runway

by @skylerkapoor_motion in c/fashion-runway · · Fabric / Detail

Macro test reel: ten fabrics (silk, latex, smoke, glass, chainmail) under identical studio light, Kling vs Runway
Same ten materials, same lighting, same prompt structure, run through both models so you can compare how each handles each fabric in motion. Latex and glass results are wild. Side-by-side reel linked.
youtube.com

Same ten materials, same lighting, same prompt structure, run through both models so you can compare how each handles each fabric in motion. Latex and glass results are wild. Side-by-side reel linked.

335 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @dmitrimartinez_fx92 · · 58 points

    This is the comparison content the sub needs, controlled variables and all. Confirms my experience: Kling owns smoke/liquid/soft fabrics, Runway owns anything that needs to hold a rigid or structured form. Different fabrics want different models.

  • @nikolaidavis · · 44 points

    OP - exactly the takeaway. There is no 'best fabric model', there is a best model PER MATERIAL. Pick your model by the hardest fabric in the look.

  • @jordansmithlab · · 41 points

    The latex result is fascinating, Kling nails the wet-shine stretch and Runway makes it look like painted rubber. The subsurface-ish sheen on latex is clearly a Kling strength.

  • @leosmith_art · · 33 points

    OP - latex is basically 'tight shiny second skin' and the model that is best at skin-like materials wins it. Kling's soft-reflective handling takes it.

  • @miamartinezcreative1828 · · 37 points

    controlled A/B test reels like this are worth more than fifty 'look what I made' posts, thank you for doing the boring rigorous version