Be honest: at what zoom level does your best work actually fall apart?

by @felixcosta2303 in c/photorealism ·

Everyone's stuff looks real at fit-to-screen. Where does YOUR best piece break when someone zooms in?

  • Holds at 100%, breaks at 200% (65 votes)
  • Breaks the moment you go past fit-to-screen (46 votes)
  • Holds to 400%, dies at pixel-peep (60 votes)
  • Genuinely holds at any zoom (sure, Jan) (63 votes)
  • I only ever check at fit-to-screen (coward) (55 votes)

289 votes · poll closed

284 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @sakuracostacreative · · 71 points

    'Holds at fit, breaks at 200%' for me and it's almost always the micro-detail running out, the model 'decided' how much detail to render and past that zoom there's nothing underneath, just smooth bluff. Real photos have information all the way down, mine has a detail floor.

  • @pavelpark_vfx · · 53 points

    The 'detail floor' is such a good way to put it. A real high-MP shot keeps rewarding zoom. AI output has a resolution of INTENT, not of capture, and you hit the bottom of what it bothered to imagine.

  • @pia_sound · · 62 points

    voted 'I only check at fit-to-screen' because I am, in fact, a coward, and if I never zoom in I never have to confront the lie

  • @williamthompsonpro866 · · 44 points

    the willful-ignorance vote is the most relatable one on the board honestly. what the eye doesn't peep, the heart doesn't grieve.

  • @sakurasantos · · 47 points

    'genuinely holds at any zoom (sure, Jan)' having votes is sending me. the person who voted that has a reflection tell they haven't found yet.