Hot take: 90% of 'cinematic' shots here are just shallow depth of field and a teal-orange grade

by @sakurasmith_studio in c/cinematic-shorts · · Mood Piece

Gonna annoy people. Shallow DoF + teal-orange + slow push-in has become the 'cinematic' starter pack and it's the video equivalent of the canvas-texture-overlay crowd next door in oil-painting. It LOOKS cinematic in a thumbnail and says nothing.

Real cinematic language is about what the shot MEANS — why this lens, why this light, why hold HERE. A blurry background and an orange grade is a costume, not composition. Half the top posts this week are the same beautiful empty push-in on a pretty face with bokeh. Gorgeous. Interchangeable. Forgettable.

The single-shot format is supposed to force intentionality and instead a lot of us found a formula that looks expensive and requires no thought. Prove me wrong. Post a shot where the choices MEAN something, not just look nice.

88 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @emmasantos_vfx · · 95 points

    counterpoint with receipts: [posts a locked wide of an empty diner at 3am, no push-in, no shallow DoF, deep focus, hard fluorescent]. sometimes the ANTI-cinematic choice is the cinematic one. deep focus and ugly light can mean more than bokeh. OP's right that the formula is lazy.

  • @hanawrightlab · · 61 points

    this diner shot does more with hard flat fluorescent than any bokeh push-in this week. deep focus = everything matters = loneliness. you proved OP's point better than OP did.

  • @oscarnguyen_art · · 70 points

    downvoting the tone, upvoting the content, the eternal fate of the guy who's right but mean. the teal-orange observation is just true though.

  • @marcuslee_ai · · 96 points

    You're the 'correct but insufferable' guy every sub has and you're correct. The shallow-DoF-teal-orange starter pack IS the new default slop. But also, learning the formula is a STAGE, not a sin. Let people have their bokeh phase.

  • @oscarmillerworks · · 70 points

    'let people have their bokeh phase' is right. everyone goes through the teal-orange chrysalis before they emerge with actual taste. OP's gatekeeping a developmental stage.