Best model for truly FLAT color right now?

by @hiroshilee in c/pop-art ·

The eternal pop-art struggle is getting flat graphic color instead of rendered realism. Which model fights you least on flatness?

  • Midjourney (stylize low) (100 votes)
  • Soul (85 votes)
  • Seedance stills (86 votes)
  • None, I posterize everything in post (109 votes)

380 votes · poll closed

374 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @oliviawilliams · · 100 points

    'None, I posterize everything in post' is the honest answer and it's winning for a reason. EVERY model is trained on continuous-tone images and fights flatness. The reliable flat look comes from YOU reducing it after, not from the prompt. Stop expecting flat from a photo-trained model.

  • @oscarnguyencreative · · 82 points

    Posterize-in-post is model-agnostic and bulletproof. The 'which model is flattest' debate is kind of moot because the answer is 'the one you flatten yourself'. Generate for composition, flatten for style.

  • @nikolaimuellercreative · · 70 points

    Midjourney with stylize cranked DOWN gets closest natively, in my experience. High stylize adds painterly rendering which is the enemy of flat. Low stylize + 'flat vector' keeps it graphic. But yeah, still posterize after.

  • @ravicosta_art · · 56 points

    Soul surprised me, it holds a flat graphic look better than I expected if you prompt 'screenprint' hard. Still not perfectly flat but less fighting than MJ for me. Model preferences on this are weirdly personal though.