Critique welcome: my floating city feels fake and I cannot figure out why

by @elenadaviscreative in c/architecture · · Critique Welcome

I have made maybe 30 versions of this speculative floating city and every single one triggers the 'this is AI' response even from me. I cannot place what is wrong. The buildings are detailed, the light is nice, the composition is balanced.

What I suspect but want confirmed: is it that nothing explains HOW it floats? There is no mechanism, no mass of engines, no tethers, no logic. It just hovers because I said so.

Be brutal. Critique Welcome flair is on. I want this to be good.

48 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @oliviawatanabe_films · · 38 points

    it is not the floating mechanism. it is that everything is the SAME distance away. there is no atmospheric depth. real distance desaturates and blues out. your far buildings are as crisp as your near ones.

  • @victorpark_art1614 · · 25 points

    oh my god. that is it. I have been staring at this for a week and it is aerial perspective. everything is on one plane. thank you.

  • @dianaleelab · · 20 points

    secondary issue: the shadows under the city do not fall on anything. a floating thing still casts a shadow on the clouds or ground below. yours casts into void.

  • @sashajohnsoncreative · · 12 points

    good catch, there is nothing receiving the shadow so the brain reads it as a sticker pasted on the sky

  • @sashabrownworks · · 14 points

    honestly the mechanism-of-floating thing matters LESS than people think, Laputa never explained it either. depth and shadow are your real problems.