Ben-Day dots: generate them or overlay them in post?

by @sophiapatel_vfx in c/pop-art ·

The core technical fork of this whole sub. Where do you land on the dots?

  • Generate in the model (89 votes)
  • Overlay/build in post (75 votes)
  • Hybrid: generate base, dot in post (91 votes)
  • Vector it all, dots included (95 votes)

350 votes · poll closed

344 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @miamiller9476 · · 100 points

    Overlay in post, full stop. The model CANNOT give you a clean regular dot grid, it gives you 'dot-like texture' that swims and varies randomly. Real Ben-Day is a precise mechanical grid. You build that in post, mapped to the posterized tones. The model does the picture, you do the dots.

  • @skyleryamamoto_ai · · 82 points

    Generating dots is like generating text, the model makes the IMPRESSION of a dot grid without the actual regular structure. For authentic Ben-Day you need a real grid you control. Post every time.

  • @kaigupta_creates838 · · 68 points

    Hybrid for me: I let the model give me a generally graphic base, but the dots themselves are always a post overlay keyed to the tone map. Trusting the model with the actual dots is how you get that boiling random-dot mush.

  • @masonchen_creates · · 53 points

    Vector-it-all gang. If I'm already tracing to vector for hard edges (which pop art needs), adding a proper vector halftone in the same pass is trivial and gives perfect scalable dots. Do the whole finish in vector and stop fighting raster mush.