Ben-Day dots: generate them or overlay them in post?
The core technical fork of this whole sub. Where do you land on the dots?
- Generate in the model
- Overlay/build in post
- Hybrid: generate base, dot in post
- Vector it all, dots included
The core technical fork of this whole sub. Where do you land on the dots?
Overlay in post, full stop. The model CANNOT give you a clean regular dot grid, it gives you 'dot-like texture' that swims and varies randomly. Real Ben-Day is a precise mechanical grid. You build that in post, mapped to the posterized tones. The model does the picture, you do the dots.
Generating dots is like generating text, the model makes the IMPRESSION of a dot grid without the actual regular structure. For authentic Ben-Day you need a real grid you control. Post every time.
Hybrid for me: I let the model give me a generally graphic base, but the dots themselves are always a post overlay keyed to the tone map. Trusting the model with the actual dots is how you get that boiling random-dot mush.
Vector-it-all gang. If I'm already tracing to vector for hard edges (which pop art needs), adding a proper vector halftone in the same pass is trivial and gives perfect scalable dots. Do the whole finish in vector and stop fighting raster mush.