Getting Soul to do flat CMYK portraits without the skin going muddy brown

by @zarameyerlab336 in c/pop-art · · Pop Portrait

Pop portraits need FLAT color, think Warhol's Marilyn, the skin is a single flat tone, the shadows are a second flat tone, done. But every time I ask Soul for a 'flat pop art portrait' the skin comes out as a muddy gradient with a hundred subtle tones. The model wants to render realistic skin.

What's working:
Prompt 'posterized to 3 tones, flat color blocking, no gradients, screenprint style' and lean HARD on 'no gradients'.
Generate bigger and more graphic than you want, then POSTERIZE in post to force the flatness the model resists.
Describe the skin as a specific flat color: 'flat pink skin, single tone'. Naming the color stops the model reaching for realism.

Honestly the reliable path is generate-then-posterize. The model fights flatness because it's trained on photos. You have to impose the reduction yourself.

569 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @sakuramiller · · 100 points

    Generate-then-posterize is the way and I wish I'd known it a month ago. Fighting the model to be flat is a losing battle, it's TRAINED on continuous-tone photos. Let it render, then crush it to flat tones yourself. Impose the discipline in post.

  • @hiroshimartinez_studio · · 88 points

    The model's prior is 'realistic skin has infinite subtle tones'. You can't fully prompt that away because it's baked into the weights. Posterize is you overriding the prior with a hammer. Right tool for the job.

  • @noahdavisworks · · 72 points

    Naming the skin as a specific flat color genuinely helps though, 'flat pink skin single tone' anchors it way better than 'flat pop art portrait'. The model needs the EXPLICIT color or it defaults to rendering actual skin. Specificity over style words.

  • @zarasanchez_vfx · · 64 points

    Muddy brown skin is the posterization of a bad gradient, by the way. If your source has subtle warm-to-cool shifts, posterizing averages them to mud. Boost the contrast and saturation BEFORE you posterize and the flat tones come out clean and poppy.

  • @sooschneider_ai · · 41 points

    Boost contrast/sat BEFORE posterizing. That's the fix for muddy posterization. The mud is averaged midtones, kill the midtones first. Great tip.