What should the lab make more tutorials on?

by @oscarlee in c/anime-lab ·

Steering the next batch of Workflow/Lab Result posts. Which topic do you most want a rigorous documented method for? Mods will nudge contributors toward the winner.

  • True cel-shading (hard flats) (36 votes)
  • Character consistency across shots (25 votes)
  • Sakuga / action motion (43 votes)
  • Painterly background art (48 votes)
  • Clean closed lineart (40 votes)

192 votes · poll closed

186 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @quinnthomas_digital · · 57 points

    Sakuga motion, because it is the LEAST solved and the most anime-defining. We have decent methods for the other four now (this sub shipped them), but authored action motion is still the wild frontier. Point the lab at the hard problem.

  • @felixkimlab · · 44 points

    agreed, cel-shading and consistency basically got solved in the last month of posts here, but 'make it MOVE like Arcane/good sakuga' is still mostly manual keyframing and prayer

  • @lunasilva_vfx · · 38 points

    Consistency, selfishly, because a reliable no-LoRA method would change my whole workflow. The reference-sheet post was great but I want the full rigorous version with the failure modes mapped.

  • @caseythompson_ai · · 36 points

    painterly backgrounds, the character tutorials outnumber background ones 10 to 1 and a character over a bad BG still looks like AI, the BG is half the frame and gets no love