Fantasy maps: hand-drawn parchment with sea-monsters in the margins, or satellite-real terrain?

by @ameliavermacreative in c/fantasy-worlds · · Map

The two schools of fantasy cartography. The romantic hand-inked scroll with 'here be dragons,' or the god's-eye satellite realism where every river and ridge is physically true. Which does this sub prefer?

  • Hand-drawn parchment, sea monsters in the margins (28 votes)
  • Satellite-realistic, every ridge and river true (50 votes)
  • Stylized videogame world-map (readable over pretty) (28 votes)
  • Isometric 3D relief you could almost walk (42 votes)

148 votes · poll closed

143 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @rileytanakaworks · · 52 points

    satellite-real for WORLDBUILDING (so your rivers and climates actually make sense, see the watershed post) but render the FINAL presentation as hand-drawn parchment, do the hard geography underneath and the pretty POV on top, best of both

  • @omaralmeidaworks97 · · 33 points

    this is the move, correct geography as the skeleton, parchment styling as the skin, the hand-drawn LOOK doesn't have to mean hand-drawn (wrong) geography

  • @noahsmith_studio · · 73 points

    hand-drawn parchment every time, a map is an ARTIFACT a character made, it should carry their biases, their blank 'unexplored' spaces, their monsters doodled in the ocean, a satellite-perfect map has no POV and a map without a point of view is just a GPS

  • @ameliaclark_motion32 · · 48 points

    the 'unexplored blank spaces' point is everything, a hand-drawn map tells you what the MAPMAKER knew and didn't, the fog of their ignorance is worldbuilding, satellite realism knows everything and so reveals nothing about who drew it

  • @jamestanaka_ai7825 · · 38 points

    isometric 3D relief is underrated, a map you could almost walk into, it's where the parchment romance and the spatial clarity meet, the videogame world-map aesthetic is genuinely the most readable