Asked Kling for a calm lake at dawn and it gave me a lake that is clearly in physical pain

by @hiroshimartinez_ai in c/experimental · · Failed Beautifully

Posting this as the platonic ideal of Failed Beautifully. Simple prompt, 'a calm lake at dawn, mist, still water, peaceful.' I wanted a boring stock shot for a background.

What I got: the water surface is calm for about one second, then it starts to BREATHE, the whole lake inhaling. The mist moves against the wind. The reflection of the trees is reaching UP toward the real trees like it wants to leave the water. By second 4 the lake has the energy of something trying very hard to appear calm while absolutely not being calm.

I have never gotten a result that failed so far past my intention into something better. I set out for 'peaceful stock loop' and Kling handed me 'a body of water having a quiet crisis.' Keeping it forever. Prompt was genuinely just the four words above, seed in a reply, I take no credit, the model did this on its own.

385 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @hiroshimueller_art · · 91 points

    'a body of water having a quiet crisis' is the single funniest and most accurate description of an AI failure i have ever read. the reflection reaching UP toward the real trees is genuinely unsettling, it WANTS something.

  • @jordanwatanabepro33 · · 58 points

    the model gave the reflection desire. you asked for calm and it gave you YEARNING. this is the stuff you cannot prompt for on purpose.

  • @kaikimworks781 · · 47 points

    the mist moving against the wind is the detail that sells the wrongness. everything's 'calm' but every individual element is subtly disobeying physics. it's calm the way a liar is calm.

  • @averywhite_films507 · · 38 points

    'calm the way a liar is calm' ok this thread is just a poetry slam about a broken lake now and i love this sub

  • @natashawagner_art726 · · 28 points

    four word prompt producing this is the best argument that the interesting stuff lives in the model's defaults, not in elaborate prompting. sometimes less rope and it hangs itself beautifully