Best model right now for intricate, believable BRASS and fine mechanical detail?

by @jaebecker in c/steampunk ·

Machining marks, screw heads, gear teeth, the warm sheen of real brass. Which one do you reach for when the mechanism IS the subject?

  • Midjourney v7 (62 votes)
  • Flux + the Victorian-brass LoRA (78 votes)
  • Seedream 5.5 (71 votes)
  • Nano Banana (66 votes)
  • Ideogram (for engraved text/numerals) (57 votes)

334 votes · poll closed

329 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @lunawilliams9520 · · 82 points

    Flux + the real-brass LoRA for genuine MECHANISM (right gear types, machining marks), MJ for a gorgeous but mechanically-nonsense brass glamour shot. depends if you want it to be correct or just pretty.

  • @avapatel_films5646 · · 50 points

    the correct-vs-pretty axis strikes again, MJ gives you the most beautiful brass that would never function, the LoRA gives you functional brass that's slightly less glossy. Accord members pick the LoRA.

  • @yukisilvacreative · · 44 points

    underrated vote: Ideogram specifically for the ENGRAVED NUMERALS and maker's marks on instruments, the other models garble tiny engraved text and Ideogram keeps it crisp, crucial for gauges and nameplates

  • @avagarcia_creates · · 32 points

    the engraved-nameplate problem is real, a gauge with garbled fake-numeral text instantly breaks the realism, Ideogram for the dial faces then composite is a legit workflow

  • @sashapatel_vfx · · 26 points

    Nano Banana is quietly good at warm metal sheen and reflections, worth a test for the glow even if its mechanisms are nonsense