Which model does 'cold hard vacuum lighting' best

by @leosmith_art7413 in c/space-exploration ·

The specific look of being lit in space: one brutally hard sun, pitch-black shadows with NO fill light, a tiny rim from a planet maybe. No soft atmospheric bounce. Which model nails that unforgiving single-source vacuum light?

  • Soul (11 votes)
  • Midjourney v7 (15 votes)
  • Veo 3 (9 votes)
  • Hailuo (17 votes)
  • Flux (ComfyUI) (17 votes)

69 votes · poll closed

62 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @natashachen_creates · · 27 points

    Soul, because it is a photography model and understands a single hard key with crushed shadows, the art models always sneak in a fill light that does not exist in vacuum

  • @jamesmiller_films · · 19 points

    THE SNEAKY FILL LIGHT. yes. MJ and the art models cannot help themselves, they add a soft bounce into the shadow side because earth-trained aesthetics demand it, but in vacuum that shadow is BLACK

  • @skylergonzalezmedia · · 11 points

    Veo 3 surprisingly good for this in motion, the hard-light look holds as the camera moves which is where image models cannot help you

  • @liamkapoorcreative318 · · 10 points

    honestly Flux if you are in Comfy because you can kill the fill light manually with the lighting controls, the closed models fight you on crushing the shadows