Hot take: Hailuo 02 is overrated for anything involving hands and I'm tired of pretending

by @taylorsantos_vfx606 in c/hailuo-community · · Result

Love this community but let's be real. The physics are great, the lighting is great, and the moment a hand has to do anything other than hang limply at someone's side, it's 2022 again.

Picking up a cup? Fingers fuse. Pointing? Bonus thumb. Holding another hand? Body horror. I've burned more credits on hand-hiding choreography than on actual shots.

I still use it daily. But the 'Hailuo solved video' hype ignores that it solved the EASY half of video and the hard half (articulated human manipulation) is barely touched. Downvote me, it's true.

37 points · 10 comments

Comments

  • @chensilvalab6211 · · 61 points

    Hand-hiding choreography is a genuine skill now. Pockets, gloves, holding the object pre-posed in the keyframe so the hand never has to articulate. It's filmmaking jiu-jitsu.

  • @hanalee_creates · · 47 points

    Took the bait, downvoted, then read it and upvoted. You're annoyingly right.

  • @yukipark_studio540 · · 96 points

    You're getting the controversial flair but you're not wrong. Every model's demo reel is objects, landscapes, and people standing still for a reason.

  • @victormoore_creates · · 87 points

    The demo reels are a map of what's solved. Nobody shows a hero tying their shoelaces because it looks like a Cronenberg film.

  • @oscarwatanabeworks594 · · 37 points

    Give it the same grace we gave early faces. Hands are 18 months behind faces, that's all. They'll get there.

  • @ethanleelab · · 34 points

    Disagree that it's 'overrated.' It's correctly rated for what it's good at. YOU are asking it to do the one thing everyone knows it can't. That's a you problem.

  • @lucasalmeida_motion · · 52 points

    Fair hit. But the marketing implies general competence and newbies get burned when reality is 'great at objects, cursed at hands.'