Free spreadsheet comparing per-second cost of every major video model

by @dianameyer_vfx in c/tutorials · · Resource

Free spreadsheet comparing per-second cost of every major video model
Normalized everything to cost-per-second-of-usable-output (factoring in typical reject rate, which nobody else does). Seedance is cheapest, Runway is the premium, the rest sit in between. Blog post explains the methodology.
aipipeline.blog

Normalized everything to cost-per-second-of-usable-output (factoring in typical reject rate, which nobody else does). Seedance is cheapest, Runway is the premium, the rest sit in between. Blog post explains the methodology.

127 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @alexeiwagner_fx · · 33 points

    factoring in REJECT RATE is what makes this honest, a 'cheap' model you have to roll 10x is not cheap, this is the first cost comparison that accounts for reality

  • @rileymiller_ai · · 18 points

    the effective cost of a model with a 20% hit rate is 5x its sticker price and the naive comparisons all ignore this, thank you for doing it right

  • @victorfischer_motion · · 11 points

    interesting that Seedance comes out cheapest even after reject rate, I assumed its lower quality would mean more rerolls, but I guess the per-gen price is just that low

  • @hiroshipark_vfx · · 9 points

    yeah the per-gen is low enough that even rolling it more it wins on raw cost, though the spreadsheet notes you pay in TIME rerolling, which it cannot price

  • @lunabrown_creates · · 8 points

    would love a column for 'has audio' since Veo 3 bundling sound changes the real cost math if you would otherwise pay for sound design

  • @emmaperez_vfx · · 7 points

    good call, adding an audio column and a 'time cost' note in v2, the time you spend rerolling is a real cost the dollar figure misses