Settle it: is a beautiful glitch 'art' or just a bug you're taking credit for?

by @dmitriverma_fx in c/experimental · · Failed Beautifully

The eternal lab argument. You didn't intend the specific result. Does curating a happy accident make you the artist, or the model's lucky editor?

  • Art, curation is authorship (37 votes)
  • Just a pretty bug (36 votes)
  • Art only if reproducible (48 votes)
  • Doesn't matter, it's cool (42 votes)
  • The question is cope, make more stuff (35 votes)

198 votes · poll closed

171 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @ethansilvaworks · · 63 points

    'the question is cope, make more stuff' and it's not close. we have this debate in every AI sub and it has never once produced a single additional artwork. voted option 5 and i'm closing the thread in my heart.

  • @elenamartinez_films3306 · · 40 points

    the anti-discourse vote winning in the experimental sub is exactly correct. we break models, we don't philosophize about whether breaking them counts.

  • @jasminekumar_vfx85 · · 31 points

    it's a bug AND art, these aren't opposites, half of photography history is 'happy accident someone was smart enough to keep'

  • @victormiller_art8444 · · 44 points

    reproducible or it's just luck. i'll die on this. a happy accident you can't repeat is a lottery ticket, not a technique. the artist is the one who can summon it twice.

  • @miaparkworks · · 41 points

    counter: Pollock couldn't reproduce a specific drip either and we call him an artist. reproducibility is an engineering value, not an art one.