Critique me: 'kitchen window still life' — I think it passes but something in the light is lying

by @yukinguyen_studio in c/photorealism · · Critique Me

Morning light through a kitchen window, a few lemons, a glass of water, a ceramic bowl. Going for that quiet Dutch-but-modern thing. Flux base, heavy retouch on the glass refraction (did a Blender proxy for the water caustics).

The caustics came out great (proud of those). But the overall image has a wrongness I can't pin — I think it's the light. It FEELS like morning but something about the shadows isn't selling it. Fresh eyes?

230 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @sophialeecreative7258 · · 71 points

    The caustics ARE great, you were right to be proud. But agreeing with the shadow-angle call — and secondarily, your lemons have no translucency. Backlit citrus glows at the rind. Right now they're opaque, which reads plastic against all that nice real light.

  • @williamsuzuki_fx294 · · 29 points

    backlit lemon rind glow, adding it, you're right they look like wax fruit currently

  • @chensingh · · 99 points

    Your shadows are too SHORT and too HARD for morning. Morning light is low-angle = LONG shadows raking across the table, and it's warm but still fairly soft through a window. Yours look like high-noon shadows wearing a warm filter. The color says morning, the geometry says noon. That's your lie.

  • @jasmineoliveirapro · · 61 points

    Oh that's exactly it. I warmed the color to say 'morning' but kept the shadow geometry neutral. The shadow LENGTH is a clock and mine is set to noon. Fixing the sun angle now.

  • @leomartinezworks · · 53 points

    genuinely this is close. fix the shadow length and the lemon translucency and I think this one earns Passed the Test. the caustics already punch above what most people attempt.