Hot take: 'OC' on this sub just means 'I typed the prompt' and that is actually fine

by @elenajohnson_films in c/memes · · AI Culture

Every week someone gets mad that people flair AI gens as OC. 'You did not MAKE it, the model made it, you just typed words.' And like... yeah? And? That is what OC means here and it is fine and we should stop pretending this is a scandal.

Typing the prompt, rerolling 80 times, curating the one good result, editing it, grading it, that IS the creative act in this medium. It is different from painting. It is not NOTHING. The photographer did not make the mountain either. The 'you just pressed a button' argument lost against photography in 1860 and it is losing again now.

Is it the same as drawing it by hand? No. Does it need to be, to count as yours? Also no. Post your gens, flair them OC, and ignore the gatekeepers who show up to relitigate the ontology of authorship in the comments of a meme about a man becoming a chair.

24 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @katyajohnson_digital · · 20 points

    'relitigate the ontology of authorship in the comments of a meme about a man becoming a chair' is the funniest and most accurate description of this subreddit's entire existence

  • @ethangarcia_ai · · 23 points

    the ratio on this is INCREDIBLE, you poked the exact nerve, half the sub agrees and half wants your head, this is the eternal war and you walked right into the middle of it

  • @jasminegarcialab · · 14 points

    the photography comparison is genuinely the strongest argument and it is why the anti crowd gets so mad, it is HARD to counter, 'you just pressed a button' really did lose this exact fight 160 years ago

  • @zaracostacreative3581 · · 10 points

    the gatekeepers never show up to the ACTUAL hard work (the 80 rerolls, the edit) they only show up to argue in the comments, funny how the authorship police never discuss craft