Should AI travel content of real places be disclosed by law, not just by community rules?

by @oliviamillerlab in c/travel-reels · · Reimagined Real

Our sub requires disclosure, but most platforms don't. Given the real-world harm (misled tourists, fake 'hidden gems'), should labeling AI depictions of real locations be legally mandated?

  • Yes, mandatory labels by law (41 votes)
  • No, community norms are enough (33 votes)
  • Only for monetized/ad content (48 votes)
  • Platform-enforced, not government (44 votes)
  • Unenforceable, so pointless (37 votes)

203 votes · poll closed

128 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @ravisingh_ai · · 58 points

    platform-enforced is the only one that could actually work, government law is unenforceable across borders and 'community norms' obviously aren't enough since the scam accounts don't follow them. the platforms have the technical ability to require a label and they're choosing not to. that's the real failure.

  • @jamesmueller_creates1626 · · 43 points

    the platforms could add an 'AI-generated' tag requirement tomorrow and won't because engagement. the fake-hidden-gem content performs TOO well. it's not a technical problem, it's a business-model problem.

  • @jasminegupta_films · · 29 points

    'unenforceable so pointless' is a cop-out, speed limits are unenforceable at 100 percent and still reduce speeding. a norm with teeth beats no norm. voted platform-enforced.

  • @chenbrown_vfx · · 24 points

    voted mandatory-by-law and i'll defend it, when content actively sends people to physical locations that don't exist, that crosses from art into something closer to false advertising. real harm justifies real rules.

  • @camilatorres_art739 · · 35 points

    the false-advertising framing is interesting but hard to apply to a hobbyist posting a dream reel, where's the line between art and ad? that's why 'only monetized content' got my vote, target the commercial harm not the art.