Best lip sync tool right now for a singing AI character, be specific not loyal

by @sashacostacreative in c/music-videos · · Performance

Singing is harder than talking, long vowels, held notes, big mouth shapes. Which tool actually handles a VOCAL performance and not just dialogue? Vote and say why.

  • Runway Act-One (33 votes)
  • Hailuo sync (47 votes)
  • Kling lip sync (32 votes)
  • A dedicated sync app (40 votes)
  • Hand-animated mouth shapes (43 votes)
  • Honestly none are good yet (46 votes)

241 votes · poll closed

228 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @masonnguyen_studio6852 · · 66 points

    voted 'none are good yet' and i'm a professional. they all handle TALKING okay and SINGING badly. held notes expose them instantly, the mouth snaps to a shape and sits there dead while a real singer's whole face is working the note.

  • @lunatanaka_creates · · 44 points

    singing is a full-face athletic event and the tools treat it like talking with longer gaps. the throat, the cheeks, the eyebrows on a belted note, none of it comes through.

  • @miafischer_fx566 · · 40 points

    Act-One is the best of a mediocre bunch IF you drive it with a real reference performance, feed it an actual singer's face video and it transfers the coarticulation. driving it with audio alone is where it falls apart.

  • @liambrown_art · · 29 points

    performance transfer beats audio-to-lip every time right now. the problem is you need a real performance to transfer FROM, which defeats the 'no actors' dream for a lot of people.

  • @yukisouzalab592 · · 24 points

    hand-animating mouth shapes in 2026 sounds insane but for a hero close-up it's still the only thing that truly holds up. 8 shots, done by hand, worth it