Settle it: denoise the AI plate BEFORE or AFTER the grade?

by @nikolaianderson_fx758 in c/vfx-breakdowns ·

Recurring argument in every thread. Denoise first to clean the source, or grade first so you denoise the final look? Vote and explain yourself in the comments.

  • Before - clean the source, always (4 votes)
  • After - denoise the final look (5 votes)
  • Both, lightly, at each stage (6 votes)
  • Depends on the artifact (boil vs grain) (5 votes)

20 votes · poll closed

5 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @natashaschulzcreative · · 84 points

    'Depends on the artifact' is the mature answer. Boil = denoise before. Fine grain mismatch = handle after when you're matching final grain across elements.

  • @taylorclark_fx912 · · 95 points

    Before. You denoise the DIRT, not the LOOK. If you grade first you're amplifying the boil with your contrast curve before you even touch it. Clean source, then push it.

  • @dianasilvalab · · 70 points

    hard agree. grading up a noisy plate is like turning up a dirty speaker. fix the signal first.

  • @sophianguyenworks · · 35 points

    After gang represent, I grade to taste then clean the final so my denoise is tuned to the look I'm actually shipping