Telephone made of water, ringing in a dry lakebed. Second pass, the grade still feels wrong

by @jordanyoungpro926 in c/surrealist · · Critique Welcome

Idea: an object that can't exist (a phone of water) doing a mundane thing (ringing) in a place that denies it (a desert). The juxtaposition is the whole piece.

Technically it's a Flux still animated in Hailuo. The water-phone holds shape if you prompt 'gelatinous, held by surface tension, not splashing.' Motion is a slow trembling ring.

What's bugging me is color. I pushed it warm sepia for 'old memory' but now it just reads like a stock desert postcard. I think I want a sicklier green in the shadows. Would you cool it or lean harder into the wrongness? Grade notes very welcome.

91 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @chenpatel_studio656 · · 48 points

    cool the shadows, keep the highlights warm. split-tone it. right now it's monochrome-warm and that's why it reads stock. the green in the shadows will make the water read as alive.

  • @emmasmithworks5560 · · 31 points

    seconding split tone. put the green only where the phone is wet-dark and let the sand stay warm. contrast of temperature sells 'this doesn't belong.'

  • @camilasilva_art · · 37 points

    honestly i'd add one bead of water falling off and never landing. that's your whole piece in one gesture

  • @oscarmiller_vfx · · 14 points

    oh that's mean. in a good way. doing it.

  • @hiroshipark_art4094 · · 21 points

    the ring motion is lovely but the handset edge ripples a little too evenly, reads like a loop. desync the top and bottom ripple a few frames