Anatomy Fail contest entry: the horse has five legs and all five are correct and that's what disturbs me

by @sophiamueller_motion106 in c/ai-bloopers · · Anatomy Fail

It's not that the horse is wrong. It's that the horse is TOO right. Five legs. Each leg is a perfectly rendered, anatomically flawless horse leg. The gait even works — all five move in a plausible rhythm. The model built a five-legged horse and then animated it CORRECTLY.

This is worse than a melting mess. A melting mess is obviously broken. This is a confident, competent, internally-consistent creature that simply has one extra leg and no awareness that it shouldn't. It trots proudly. It has somewhere to be. It is using all five.

The uncanny isn't in the failure, it's in the COMPETENCE of the failure. Wan 2.2. Contest submission. I'm a little scared of it.

649 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @sergeiwhitecreative921 · · 71 points

    five-legged horse that uses all five correctly belongs in a mythology. this isn't a bug it's a cryptid. name him.

  • @yukibrown_art7433 · · 52 points

    Quintus. he has somewhere to be. do not question the fifth leg, it has served him well.

  • @ethanjohnson_films · · 99 points

    a COMPETENTLY animated extra leg is so much more cursed than a broken one. the model fully believes in the fifth leg. it has committed. there's no uncertainty for your brain to latch onto, it just trots with calm conviction

  • @lunacosta · · 98 points

    'the uncanny isn't in the failure, it's in the COMPETENCE of the failure' is a genuinely sharp observation about this whole medium. the scariest glitches are the self-assured ones.

  • @jordanwilliams_vfx · · 58 points

    this needs to be in the weekly contest. submit it before someone posts a worse version and wins on your idea.