Deco perfume bottle product render WIP - feels too modern? Honest critique wanted (before/after angles)

by @sophiakim_studio in c/art-deco · · Object / Product

Deco perfume bottle product render WIP - feels too modern? Honest critique wanted (before/after angles)
A fictional luxury Deco perfume bottle - stepped glass, a sunburst cap, fluted sides. A few people in another thread said it reads 2020s-minimalist-luxury rather than 1925-Deco and I want to pin down why. Link has it from three angles plus a real 1930s bottle for comparison.
twitter.com

A fictional luxury Deco perfume bottle - stepped glass, a sunburst cap, fluted sides. A few people in another thread said it reads 2020s-minimalist-luxury rather than 1925-Deco and I want to pin down why. Link has it from three angles plus a real 1930s bottle for comparison.

33 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @nikolainguyen_films · · 52 points

    Also the material finish reads modern - your glass is too clean/frosted-contemporary. 1930s Deco glass had sharper facets catching hard specular glints and often a metallic (chrome/gold) collar with visible machining. The MACHINE-AGE quality is missing, it looks too soft and spa-like.

  • @sakurakumarcreative517 · · 33 points

    OP - the machine-age hardness, yes, I made it feel like a modern spa product not a machine-age luxury object. Sharper facets, a chrome collar, harder speculars. The softness is the modern tell.

  • @tayloroliveira_ai · · 92 points

    It reads modern because your proportions are too SPARE and your details too FEW. 2020s luxury-minimalism and 1925 Deco both use geometry, but Deco is MAXIMALIST geometry - more steps, more facets, a denser sunburst, tighter fluting. Your bottle is Deco-SHAPED but modern-RESTRAINED. Add ornament. Deco was not shy.

  • @hiroshipark_films · · 57 points

    OP - 'Deco-shaped but modern-restrained' is EXACTLY the diagnosis I was failing to articulate, thank you. I minimalist-ized it by instinct because that reads as 'tasteful' to a modern eye, but Deco's taste was abundance within geometry. Adding density.

  • @oscarnguyenworks · · 38 points

    honestly posting it next to a real 1930s bottle for comparison is the move that makes this critique productive, half of 'why does it feel modern' is answered just by the side by side