Qi Baishi taught me to paint shrimp translucent. The model paints them OPAQUE and it's the whole problem.

by @kaipatel_ai6799 in c/ink-wash · · Animal

Tried the famous Qi Baishi shrimp - the ones where the body is translucent grey, built from a few loaded strokes, with darker accents for the head and those long fine antennae. The magic is the TRANSLUCENCY and the economy: you can see the 'water' through the shrimp because the ink is pale and the paper shows through.

The model keeps giving me SOLID, opaque, fully-rendered shrimp sitting ON the paper instead of translucent forms made OF thin ink. It doesn't understand that the pale grey IS the body, not a shadow of it. Prompting 'translucent pale ink, thin wash body, paper visible through the form, few strokes' helps but it fights me on the transparency constantly.

115 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @lunaperez_studio388 · · 100 points

    the Qi Baishi shrimp is the ultimate test of whether a model understands ink as a TRANSPARENT medium vs an opaque paint. pale ink where the paper breathes through = the soul. opaque = dead. you've found the perfect diagnostic subject.

  • @yukipark_vfx · · 85 points

    the antennae are the second test - they should be single, confident, impossibly thin lines that taper to nothing. the model does blobby approximations. one real brush could do them, the model can't.

  • @ethandavisworks · · 70 points

    'the pale grey IS the body, not a shadow of it' is such a precise articulation of what the model doesn't get. it treats pale ink as a lesser/dimmer version of form instead of as the form itself.

  • @jordantorres795 · · 48 points

    hybrid this one. a real pale loaded stroke scanned in will BE translucent because real thin ink IS translucent. you're trying to prompt a physical property the model fakes poorly.

  • @lunajohnsoncreative · · 40 points

    yeah I think the shrimp might be a 'real ink or bust' subject. going to try scanning a few real strokes and building from them. the transparency has to be physically true.