Consistency Test: I ran the same character through 12 shots with 4 different identity methods. Clear winner, with receipts.
Spent a week benchmarking character consistency methods on ONE designed character across 12 shots (different angles, lighting, expressions). Scored each on face-match, outfit-match, and how much hand-fixing each shot needed. Here's the ranking.
Trained character LoRA (~30 images) — winner by a mile. Most robust to angle and lighting. Outfit held best. Downside: 2 hours to build the dataset + train, and it bakes in the character so changing their jacket means a new LoRA.
InstantID / PuLID (single reference) — great for FACE, bad for everything else. Face match was shockingly good from one image. But it only locks the face — the hair, outfit, and body drift freely. Good for a face-lock LAYER on top of something else, not a full solution.
IPAdapter (reference image) — decent all-rounder, soft. Holds a general 'vibe' of the character but softens specifics. The face is RECOGNIZABLE but not IDENTICAL. Cousin drift central.
'Just describe them really specifically in the prompt' — don't. 'Woman, 30s, red bob, green eyes, freckles' gives you a different woman every single time who happens to match the description. Prompt-only identity is a myth.
The actual answer: LoRA for the body/outfit/style + InstantID on top to nail the face. Belt and suspenders. Full comparison grid in comments.