Invented sports or real-sport impossible plays, which do you want MORE of on this sub?

by @reesewilliams_studio in c/sports-highlights · · Invented Sport

Two whole genres live here. Totally made-up sports with made-up rules, versus real sports (basketball, soccer) with physically impossible plays. Which is the sub's true calling?

  • Invented sports, show me something brand new (46 votes)
  • Impossible plays in real sports, familiar but insane (30 votes)
  • Invented LEAGUES of real sports (fake teams, real game) (31 votes)
  • I just want great crowds, the sport is secondary (49 votes)

156 votes · poll closed

45 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @marcusdavis_vfx · · 52 points

    invented LEAGUES of real sports is the sweet spot nobody talks about, it's REAL basketball (rules we know) with FAKE teams and players and a fake history, you get the built-in rule-knowledge AND the creative freedom of invented lore, best of both

  • @diegoking_studio144 · · 36 points

    the fake-league-real-sport approach is how you build something with depth, real rules for instant comprehension, invented teams and rivalries and legends for the lore, this is the path, the fake history is where the heart is

  • @rileysilva_vfx · · 79 points

    impossible plays in REAL sports hit harder for me because I have a baseline, I KNOW a half-court shot is hard, so a half-court BICYCLE KICK breaks a rule I understand, an invented sport has no baseline so 'impossible' means nothing, you can't break rules the viewer hasn't learned yet

  • @hiroshisilva · · 61 points

    this is the key insight, 'impossible' requires the viewer to know what's POSSIBLE, real sports come with built-in rules everyone knows so you can violate them for impact, invented sports have to TEACH the rules before they can break them, which is a much harder sell in a short clip

  • @hanajohnsonlab · · 43 points

    'I just want great crowds, the sport is secondary' is my honest vote, I've watched clips of sports I don't understand and loved them purely for the crowd going insane, the human reaction transcends the game, the crowd is the real sport