Why does rain always fall at exactly the same angle no matter what wind I prompt

by @chensingh_studio in c/neon-nights · · Rain

Genuine question slash complaint. I prompt 'rain driven sideways by strong wind' or 'rain falling at a steep angle in a gale' and the model gives me... the same gentle, near-vertical, evenly-spaced rain it always gives me. The rain in these models has ONE setting: polite. It does not understand wind. It does not understand GUSTS where the angle changes across the frame. It is always the same tidy diagonal drizzle.

Real rain in wind is CHAOS, different angles in different parts of the frame, sheets of it, sudden gusts, rain curving around buildings. The model's rain is a uniform screen-saver. Is anyone getting genuinely wind-driven, chaotic, angry rain out of these things, or is 'polite evenly-spaced drizzle' just the only rain the models know?

12 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @avapatelworks5897 · · 9 points

    the model's rain has exactly one mode and it is 'tasteful establishing-shot drizzle', it learned rain from stock footage and movie rain (which is also fake and uniform, real movie rain is from a rain machine) so it never saw real chaotic storm rain

  • @emmaleecreative · · 6 points

    THIS, movie rain is machine rain, uniform and backlit and fake, and that is most of the 'rain' in the training data, so the model learned Hollywood rain not real rain, it has never seen a real gale

  • @ravichenworks · · 5 points

    partial fix: do the chaotic rain as a separate composited pass (like the depth-rain thread) where YOU control the angle variation, generate multiple rain layers at different angles and combine, the model will not do chaos but you can assemble it

  • @jamessinghlab · · 4 points

    compositing chaos from multiple uniform passes is the workaround, each layer is boring uniform rain but at a different angle, stack three angles and suddenly it is a gale, the model does the parts you do the chaos

  • @alexanderperez_creates · · 4 points

    'the rain in these models has ONE setting: polite' is painfully accurate, I have never once gotten a genuine sideways gale, it is always the same well-behaved diagonal, polite rain is the only rain it knows